Authoritative and
enlightening, September 27, 2003
Reviewer:
Gisela Gasper Fitzgerald from
USA
Both authors instilled confidence in
me because they themselves are adoptive
mothers and are seeing the issue from the
inside out. I wish I had had a book such
as this when we adopted our child in 1969
at age 4 days. I was completely in the
dark as to when and how to tell our
little girl about her adoption. I only
knew that she had to be told and presumed
that it should be as early as possible.
Watkins's and Fisher's book give the
adoptive parent(s) helpful guidelines in
understanding (anticipating) the young
adoptee's questions and concerns and are
encouraged to be as natural as possible
talking to their children any time the
children bring up the topic. I would like
mention one research study that tells us
when we can expect adoptees truly to
understand the notions of birth and
adoption. In their book, Openness in
Adoption, Exploring Family Connections,
Harold D. Grotevant and Ruth G. McRoy
found that the mean age of children NOT
understanding the meaning of adoption is
5.8, age range 4.9-8.8; the mean age of
children fusing the two concepts of
adoption and birth is 6.4, age range
4.7-9.6; only at the mean age of 7.5, age
range 4.7-12.9, do children clearly
differentiate between adoption and birth
as alternative paths to parenthood and
accept that the adoptive family
relationship is permanent, but do not
understand why; children at a mean age of
8.9, age range 5.4-11.9, differentiate
between adoption and birth but are unsure
about the permanence of the adoptive
parent-child relationship. The children
at this age fear that the natural parents
might reclaim them. At the mean age of
9.5, age range 6.6-12.6 the children
vaguely understand that their
relationship with their adoptive parents
is permanent because a judge, lawyer,
doctor or social worker signed some
papers. Only at the mean age of 10.5, age
range 8.0-12.1, is the adoption
relationship fully understood with its
characterized permanency.
Gisela Gasper Fitzgerald, author of
ADOPTION: An Open, Semi-Open or Closed
Practice?